🇧🇷Brazil

Manipulação e Exclusão de Footage de Câmeras Corporais na Plataforma de Armazenamento

2 verified sources

Definition

The PMSP system demonstrates a proven scheme where authorized users (including at least one major linked to command) can delete original body camera footage within 90 days of recording by exploiting the Axon platform's file regeneration feature. Officers intentionally fill camera memory to disable recording for days. Deleted footage cannot be recovered, and cases with manipulated evidence are rejected by courts.

Key Findings

  • Financial Impact: Estimated: R$ 500,000–2,000,000 annually per large state PM (costs: lost cases, retrials, disciplinary investigations, reputational damage); unquantified liability from wrongful convictions or dismissed cases due to evidence tampering.
  • Frequency: Ongoing; discovered in Jul 2025 for PMSP; likely systemic across 20+ states using similar platforms.
  • Root Cause: Lack of cryptographic immutability and redundant backup verification; insufficient audit logging; inadequate access controls; no independent witness chain for file modifications.

Why This Matters

Pitch: Brazilian law enforcement agencies (PMSP, other state PMs) lose investigative credibility and expose themselves to litigation when fraudulently-modified footage is presented in court. Implementing forensic-grade immutable storage and audit trail enforcement eliminates deletion schemes and protects departments from evidence-tampering scandals.

Affected Stakeholders

PMSP command staff, Evidence custodians, Prosecutors, Defense attorneys, Trial judges

Deep Analysis (Premium)

Financial Impact

Financial data and detailed analysis available with full access. Unlock to see exact figures, evidence sources, and actionable insights.

Unlock to reveal

Current Workarounds

Financial data and detailed analysis available with full access. Unlock to see exact figures, evidence sources, and actionable insights.

Unlock to reveal

Get Solutions for This Problem

Full report with actionable solutions

$99$39
  • Solutions for this specific pain
  • Solutions for all 15 industry pains
  • Where to find first clients
  • Pricing & launch costs
Get Solutions Report

Methodology & Sources

Data collected via OSINT from regulatory filings, industry audits, and verified case studies.

Evidence Sources:

Related Business Risks

Falta de Padronização e Conformidade em Retenção de Dados de Câmeras Corporais entre Estados

Estimated: R$ 1,000,000–5,000,000 annually across all 20 states (cost of retrials, case reopenings, dismissed charges, prosecutorial hours spent re-investigating).

Atraso em Cadeia de Custódia - Processamento Manual de Evidências e Gargalos Operacionais

LOGIC estimate: 30-50 hours/month per crime lab × R$150/hour (loaded cost) × 12 months = R$54,000-90,000 annual labor cost per lab. With ~100 public crime labs in Brasil = R$5.4M-9M national annual drag.

Não-Conformidade em Planos de Ação do FNSP e Retenção de Repasses

R$ 87,8 milhões não-executados em 2003 (queda de 25% em execução). Projeção atual: considerando que transferências obrigatórias anuais variam entre R$ 722-765 milhões (Fonte [6]), uma taxa de atraso de 20-25% por não-conformidade administrativa equivale a R$ 144-191 milhões em capital de giro bloqueado anualmente em nível federal.

Subexecução Orçamentária Estrutural do FNSP e Desperdício de Empenho

R$ 87,8 milhões não-executados em 2003 (queda de ~25%). Projeção: considerando R$ 755-765 milhões transferidos anualmente (Fonte [6]), uma taxa de subexecução de 20-25% equivale a R$ 151-191 milhões/ano em investimentos de segurança perdidos ou atrasados.

Falta de Visibilidade em Execução Física vs. Orçamentária do FNSP

Custo de auditoria retroativa estimado em 300-500 horas/ano por estado (8 equipes de auditores federais × 27 estados = ~40-70 auditorias anuais). A taxa horária de auditor federal é ~R$ 200-300/hora. Perda: R$ 2,4-10,5 milhões/ano em retrabalho de conformidade. Além disso, falta de dados impede realocação ótima de R$ 144-191 milhões em recursos represados entre estados com maior demanda/performance.

Uso Não Autorizado e Desvio de Combustível em Frotas Policiais

Estimated R$ 15,000-45,000 per 100-vehicle fleet annually (5-8% of fuel budget; typical fleet fuel cost: R$ 180,000-280,000/year). Based on 27 state police forces averaging 2,000 vehicles each: ~R$ 81-243 million national leakage annually.

Request Deep Analysis

🇧🇷 Be first to access this market's intelligence